UK HS2: northern publicity shouldn’t give Sunak chilly toes

Obtain free Lex updates

We’ll ship you a myFT Each day Digest e mail rounding up the newest Lex information each morning.

There may be an air of melancholic inevitability about infrastructure tasks that price double their unique finances. The £12bn Channel Tunnel was only one instance. But the scale of the cost overrun of the UK’s HS2 rail challenge is really one thing particular. The anticipated £91bn price ticket is greater than twice the 2010 estimate for a extra bold scheme.

No marvel Rishi Sunak desires to reduce the north-south high-speed rail challenge. The prime minister is reportedly planning to axe a spur to Manchester. The estimated savings of just about £30bn attraction to a cash-strapped authorities.

But such a transfer would additionally cut back the capability and connectivity beneficial properties wanted to have any probability of justifying the challenge. Capitalised prices had been all the time at least twice as high because the capitalised worth of passenger revenues as soon as in operation, based on Imperial School professor Stephen Glaister. 

The capability constraints on north-south rail hyperlinks — normally cited as HS2’s principal justification — have been eased by post-pandemic adjustments in working practices. Passenger numbers are about 20 per cent decrease than pre-Covid ranges, adjusted for the appearance of London’s new Elizabeth line.

Diminished commuter occasions and widening labour catchment areas can improve agglomeration advantages. However the extent of those beneficial properties will be exaggerated. Door-to-door journey occasions most likely must be lower than an hour to depend. Higher regional transport hyperlinks are more likely to supply better productiveness advantages than long-distance hyperlinks. 

The impression on the development business is one other issue, although no contracts have been awarded for the northern leg but. Costain and Kier are most uncovered to HS2. However cancelling the second section is unlikely to have a near-term impression, based on Liberum’s Joe Brent.

But there may be an comprehensible want to get one thing of worth to indicate for the large sums already expended on the challenge. In 2021, the Treasury assessed the longer HS2 route as providing “low-to-medium” worth for cash. That’s hardly a ringing endorsement. However it’s higher than a cut-down London-Birmingham line, which was rated “low worth for cash”.

Cancelling the Manchester leg would go away HS2 as little greater than a shuttle between a west London suburb and Birmingham. That will be a parody of its unique goal. It will put HS2 on observe to rival Concorde because the epitome of presidency folly.